I can agree with almost all of what you said, and any disagreement is not worth mentioning. All these points have been talked about on here over the years, but it's always good to summarize again, so new readers can see the errors listed again. I do believe most in the LC are real believers, but as you say, at "the very least it is a cult of personality." Quite true with the extreme emphasis on the man, Witness Lee.
On the recently closed, "Examining LC Spinoffs" thread, I listed eight things that we in Scottsdale (a so-called LC spinoff), "have seen and freely acknowledge & repudiate among ourselves" concerning WL/LSM/LC teachings and practices (a few of which you already mentioned with some additional).
"Below from Examining LC Spinoffs" thread post #28
Quote:
1. The teaching of fear as the basis of performance - e.g., a thousand years in outer darkness or God being out to whack us for whatever is way off! (In reality, His banner over us is love and is the real reason why He has His eternal purpose)
2. The centralized control
3. The "God becoming Man so man can become God" teaching
4. The so-called "Ground of Oneness" which was really eletism
5. The degrading of other Christians
6. The myriad covert rules and regulations (albeit often conveyed by LC culture)
7. The focus on Lee as the one whatever
8. The teaching that God is not moving among any others; that no other Christian authors have a fresh experience of Christ or have received fresh revelation (therefore don't go looking for other good Christian sources, because there aren't any!)
|
This list is certainly not meant to be all-inclusive, but was just a start to base the conversation on (though these points were not really addressed much in that thread).